The major difference in ‘Magnatec Vs. Edge’ is- The first one is thicker and the latter is thinner. Also, Magnatec concentrates on preventing engine wear-out, whereas Edge focuses on the pressure management of the engine.
Magnatec and Edge are different versions of Castrol oil, a well-known oil manufacturing industry. Both are fully synthetic and premium-grade oils. However, Edge is more advanced than Magnatec. The difference between these two is subtle, which creates more tension when choosing one.
Another fact is that Edge is a bit more expensive than Magnatec. Despite that, we want the best for our traveling companion and engine oil is something we should not be thrifty about. This discussion will be helpful for people whose major concern is ‘Magnatec Vs. Edge’
Castrol Magnatec Vs. Edge Comparison in a Table
|Comparison||Castrol Magnatec||Castrol Edge|
|Performance||Better than other conventional oils||Best performance of all time|
|Durability||Lasts longer||Comparatively shorter lifespan than Magnatec|
|Customer’s rating(According to Amazon)||87% of the 4.8 rating||89% of 4.8 rating|
What Is Castrol Magnatec?
Magnatec is a fully synthetic engine oil manufactured by Castrol. It has force-field protection and patented ‘Dualock’ technology. Castrol Magnatec can reduce engine wear by up to 75%, according to specialists.
The intelligent molecules of Magnatec oil form an extra layer of protection during the critical warm-up period. These critical molecules cling to the important part of the engine and keep it smoother. Magnatec is available in 0W-16, 0W-20, 5W-30 A5, 5W-40 A3/B4, and 10W-40A variants.
- DualShock technology
- Intelligent molecules
- Instant protection
What is Castrol Edge?
Castrol’s Edge is an advanced full synthetic 5W-30 relatively new invention. They have honed the Fluid Titanium Technology (FTT) in order to create fully synthetic oil. Edge, despite being new to the market, is already well-known for its low friction and high performance. Edge is available in a few versions, such as Edge high mileage, Extended performance, Bio-synthetic, supercar, and Euro.
In Fluid Titanium Technology, the titanium polymer collaborates with fluid strength and they work together. This aspect made this oil more desirable than the other ones. The FTT reduces a significant amount of friction and oil-coating. Minimizing friction eventually leads to less pressure on the engine. That is why Edge is notable for handling extreme pressure quite well.
- Full synthetic oil
- Fluid Titanium Technology
- No oil-coating
- Six times stronger than other oils.
Things Worth Knowing About Oil Blends
When choosing oil for vehicles, the limited idea about oil blends creates problems for most of the users. Based on the blend type, oils can be divided into three categories: Conventions, Synthetic, and Fully Synthetic.
Conventional motor oils have a singular petroleum base. This blend is thick when the temperature is low and thin when the temperature is high. Over time, it breaks down. In recent times, conventional oils have lost their popularity however, old engines still use them.
Synthetic or semi-synthetic oil is a mixture of a singular petroleum base and chemically modified petroleum components. The combination makes them less likely to wear over time. Also, they are prepared to match multi-grade oils. Synthetic oils can be found in a wide range of engines.
Fully-synthetic oil blend is considered pure petroleum oil. Which is more advanced than the semi-synthetic blend. This blend is the most famous oil blend in recent times between both users and experts. This oil blend is less likely to oxidize or acidify and more likely to sustain for a longer period. Almost all car manufacturing companies are using fully synthetic blends in their recent engines.
When you know these differences you can choose the right oil for your engine.
Magnatec Vs. Edge: Major Differences
Most of the cars in the USA are high-performance-oriented and ultra-efficient in nature. However, there are two drawbacks of highly efficient engines- temperature and friction. The engines that are produced for high performance go through extreme pressure and create an excess amount of temperature.
Both of the oil from Castrol is capable of handling excessive pressure and temperature. Between Magnatec and Edge, the second one is better at handling such extreme pressure. Edge reduces engine friction like magic but Magnatec prevents oil breakdowns better in hot temperatures because of its thickness.
Preventing ‘Stop-Start’ Wearing
Every engine’s 75% wear happened from the first twenty minutes of the warm-up session. We know this as ‘start-wear’. The rest of the wear comes from stopping wearing. Castrol Magnatec oil prevents this stop-start wear of the engine more efficiently than Castrol Edge. No wonder why Magnatec keeps the engines safer.
Viscosity refers to the capability of oil to pour easily at a specific temperature. Thin oils have low viscosity which indicates that they can reach faster and more effectively the inside components of an engine more. For this reason, thin oil can prevent friction more successfully than thicker oil.
Castrol Magnatec is thicker and Edge is thinner at an average temperature. So we can conclude that Edge is more effective in reducing friction.
The cleaning properties help with the general maintenance and working conditions of the vehicles. With the right oil, you can make a 180-degree turn even with a badly worn engine. And Castrol Edge is better at cleaning properties than Castrol Magnatec.
Castrol Edge might be the most advanced and high-functioning oil in recent times but its life span is shorter than Castrol Magnatec. The thick and intelligent molecules of Magnatec stick better and longer into the critical parts of the engine, meaning also a longer use of the oil.
Magnatec Vs. Edge: Pros and Cons
|-Reduce both warm-up and stop-start wear|
-1.4x better protection against sludge
-Make critical engine parts smoother
-Sufficient amount of Lubricant available Lasts longer
-The strongest one
-Extraordinary performance under pressure
-Improve fuel economy
-Suitable for most European as well as American cars
-Good at cold starts
Every product has some inherent limitations in this case those are:
|Bad at cold start||Shorter life span|
Magnatec Vs. Edge: How to choose?
Castrol Magnatec is good for heavy traffic-prone areas, where your engine has to face frequent start-stop situations. Because of its clinginess, Magnatec gives a smooth start.
On the other hand, if your engine goes through a lot of pressure, you need high-functioning oil, and continuous coverage for a longer time then Castrol Edge is the best catch.
Therefore, despite being both good oils, the Castrol Edge is ahead of Magnatec for sure.
Our final verdict is that both oils are good oil, however, that is not the answer you want to hear right? For this, we would like to suggest you go through the manufacturer’s recommendations first. Following that, set your preferences. Hope this Castrol ‘Magnatec Vs. Edge differentiation helps you to choose the right one for your engine.